quality VS quantity

so I have been looking all around this city and surrounding cities for a videographer. to my dismay i have found 4 and 2/4 are booked. so the remaining 2 are very different. we only budgeted 1K for video b/c we spent a great deal of on photog. So we have been debating b/w the 2. Both vids have the same pricing.

• Video #1 is offering bride and groom interviews before the wedding "love story", coverage of both rehearsal and dinner, all day wedding coverage pre-ceremony thru reception departure, and a video photomontage for $1300. THE BAD: his quality is not the greatest.

• Video #2 is offering 6 hr coverage but he has GREAT work! Cinematic movies.

So the question becomes QUANTITY vs QUALITY?